Saturday, January 24, 2009

Firefighter Discussion Forums –Friends or Foes Of Volunteers?

One thing that the internet has brought to society is the ability to communicate in a cyber world within nanoseconds of the enter key being depressed by the user. This gives the person unlimited access to the exchange of information at their fingertips and as such there are numerous firefighter forums that we, as firefighters can engage our fellow firefighters in whether its debate, sharing training information, discussing various calls that we go on, etc. I personally have visited numerous sites and decided that I’d share with you my experiences and give you my personal rating on each major sight I have visited. The rating will be on a scale of 1 to 5 with 5 being the highest rating. I’ll also include their web address so you can visit and make your own determination.

Firehouse.com - The website is very user-friendly and easy to use and has numbers separate forums on different topics you can use. There are forums for volunteer, career, paid-on-call, training, and the like. From my experience, they don’t appear to generate a lot of traffic forum-wise but most of the posters in the forum are legit about having honest and frank discussion, tho’ there are a few flamers and trolls in there which the moderators are quick to address. Web address: www.firehouse.com Rating: 4

Nassau Fire Rant - Before you get any negative ideas, Rant stands for: Resources. Articles. News. Training. I must say that this is one of the most clear-cut interesting firefighter forums where you can have genuine dialog on firefighting. It is volunteer-friendly and those registering are told up front that if they are there to bash volunteers, they are wasting their time. The site has a nice layout and is very easy to navigate. Posting can be tough to start up as there appears to be a waiting period before the administrators will give you posting privileges. The members who post in there appear to be a friendly lot and I’ve yet to observe any animosity among the posters. The moderators obviously ride heard on anyone violation the TOS. If you are desirous of having good open dialog about the fire service, then this is the sight for you! Web address: http://www.nassaufdrant.com/ Rating: 5+

EMT Bravo.net – They have a nice design and layout of the website. Register and fill in the information they ask of you and your good to go. Unfortunately that’s where it ends. The clientele if you will, are composed mostly of very vocal Westchester/Fairfield County, NY career firefighters, some volley-wanna be career firefighters from the Greater Metro NY area in addition to a few brave volly’s who venture into the inner sanctum of this website. A great many of the posters in the forum are anti-volly and make it known to all present. Additionally, they engage in a great deal of censorship in that forum and while they have a perfect right to do so since it is privately owned, it nonetheless it discourages open and honest dialogue. To their credit, the moderators do attempt to maintain some level of decorum in there, but if your one of their “Outstanding Member Award Winner” they tend to leave you alone and I’ve read complaints on censorship in there. If you’re career, like copious amounts of whining and enjoy reading and/or engaging in volunteer bashing, then you’ll be in your zone. Volunteers, wear helmets when posting! Web Address: www.emtbravo.net Rating: 2-

New York City Fire.net – This forum is maintained by NYFD members and is more of a place to share information on alarms attended; there is some union politics on the forum, but as NYFD is unionized it is to be expected. They appear to be volunteer friendly; probably since they don’t feel threatened by volleys and many of them are two-hatters in the towns they live in for those who live outside the city. The site is user friendly and well laid-out and is relatively easy to navigate. The only thing missing more or less is participation from more firefighters. Its an excellent site for discussion on fire ground tactics-city style and news of rescue efforts, which in NYC is a constant given the amount of runs they engage in. Its definitely worth a visit to the web site. Web Address: www.nycfire.net Rating: 3

The Watch Desk.com – Just when you thought it couldn’t get worse. A quick visit to this website found that while they have separate forums for every state, most of the traffic is generated from Pennsylvania, Virginia, West Virginia, Maryland and Orange County, New York. And with the exception of Orange County thread, all of them, almost to the man, fight with each other, whether they are career or volunteer. If you’re a church or temple going person, you’d best stay out of the site as the language in there is worse then a sailor cursing after a night out in a bar. There is a constant exchange of “colorful metaphors” between the posters in there. The moderators maintain absolutely no control over what is said and done in there and as such, the posters run wild. Its amazing, when you think of it, that some of our brother (and yes, sister) firefighters have not met up and come to blows over some silly argument. Website design and navigation is less then desirable. If I were the owners, it’s high time to retool the sight, clean up the language and jettison those who refuse to comply. Normally I would have given them a “0” for rating but since Orange county thread is rather civil, they merit at least something on the chart. Enter the website at your own risk! Web Address: www.watchdesk.com Rating 1+

There of course are many more out there, including numerous satellite forums of the ones discussed here. And while this may generate some flack from the owners of some of the forums towards me, this is something I felt that firefighters, both volunteer and career need to be made aware of.

Sunday, January 18, 2009

Volunteer vs. Paid Issues

As an active volunteer firefighter for past 33 years, I take a keen interest in the fire service and as such read and participate in a few firefighter forums. Many of them run the gamut from being objective to nothing more then volunteer bashing platforms. It amazes me of the animosity in some forums between volunteer and paid firefighters.

According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS), www.bls.gov, volunteer firefighters make up 70 percent of fire companies in the United States which are composed of 100% volunteer membership. Saving American taxpayers billions of dollars each year in taxes, these volunteers place their lives on the line everyday for no salary or real compensation. It is an American tradition that goes back to the 1700’s when Benjamin Franklin formed the first volunteer fire department to fight fires in Philadelphia.

So why is it that such animosity exists between the paid and volunteer forces? Why is the “Brotherhood/Sisterhood” fractured when it comes to employment status? Volunteers, while not compensated in most cases, mainly make a career volunteering out of spirit and a willingness to help out in the community, make a positive difference, acceptance socially and a desire for self satisfaction. Paid firefighters on the other hand are compensated for their services and for many, like their volunteer counterparts wish to make a career out helping people. While you won’t get rich being a paid firefighter, you can live comfortably and know that in 20 years, you can retire with a 50% pension benefit and full medical/life insurance policy. Not a bad deal if you don’t mind working odd hours and holidays.

I asked a friend of mine who is a paid firefighter in Westchester County, New York why, in his opinion, paid firefighters take an adversarial view towards volunteers. He told me first off that not all the paid guys resent volunteers, but there is a vocal minority that reject the volunteer concept as a threat to their livelihood and feel that volunteers do not have the same training standards as the paid crews. In other words, he told me, they feel that volunteers are not their equals. Many all-paid departments refuse to call on neighboring volunteer departments for mutual aid claiming that the level of training that volunteers is inferior to that of the paid firefighters.

While it is true that most volunteers do not have the level of training that paid types have, which I think is around 239 hours vs. 89 for volunteer basic, the volunteer fire service is structured much differently then paid. In the paid world, if you will, there is only one kind of firefighter, one who does all; interior and exterior duties all rolled into one. This is the only concept that many of them can comprehend. However in the volunteer service, by the nature of the employee, you have interior firefighters, exterior firefighters, fire-police, administrative/support-only firefighters and drivers (chauffeurs). It is structured this way because this is what works best as some members do not wish to go into burning buildings, but are fine with exterior work, some only want to do rescue (EMS) related, fire-police or driving of the apparatus. In the eyes of many volunteers, having a paid firefighter man a master stream or performing ground ladder work when he could be utilized as interior is a waste of manpower and resources and is something a volunteer could easily do thus freeing up the paid firefighter for interior duties. But in many jurisdictions, union work rules generally forbid volunteers from working with paid firefighters.

Could it really be that paid firefighters truly view us as a threat? The IAFF has publicly declared that volunteer firefighters are the “enemy” in a recent report to the membership; indeed, they have forbidden their membership to volunteer in many instances, threatening those who do with sanctions and possible expulsion from the union. Could it be true? My first reaction is no. The main reason for this is that under law if they throw out a member for anything other then non-payment of dues and/or fees, they must be allowed to continue employment with the agency employing them. This would defeat the purpose of persuading them volunteering and also financially crippling to the various locals who would lose the dues money they need to operate. They also risk members resigning from the union and converting to agency fee payer status or even worse, core membership.

The volunteers aren’t perfect angels here either; I personally know a few who resent paid firefighters because they receive monies doing something that the volunteers feel should be done as a community service thus saving taxpayers valuable dollars. Others resent the haughty attitude exhibited by paid firefighters being a mentality of “we’re professional and volunteers aren’t”. Indeed, the forums at times look like the civil war redux where one must duck for cover when reading them.

I think its high time that the paid firefighters who have this anti-volunteer attitude need to re-evaluate their positions on the volunteer fire service and likewise the volunteers who subscribe to “volunteer only” need to stop and realize that paid firefighters have their place, especially in major cities where the amount of alarms makes an all volunteer force unfeasible.

Only when both sides decide to become one and recognize the different concepts and methods of operation, will the fire service finally become what it should have been over the years. That is a band of Brothers and Sisters working together towards a common goal.

Friday, January 16, 2009

The Crusty Old Firefigther Brings In The New Year

The Crusty Old Firefighter always loves parties, especially New Years Eve parties, since he first joined the fire service so many years ago. “I wonder how this years party will turn out, after all I’m one who volunteered to put it on this time around; can’t believe I agreed to hold it at my home” he thought to himself as he sat on an old metal framed chair sorting though flat wear looking for bent or rusted pieces that might somehow sneak into the pile of freshly washed implements that the guests would be using later that night. “God forbid if Joe Slick, one of the more senior members of the department got a bent fork stuck in his rather extensive dentures and ended up breaking or even worse pulling out the entire saliva-covered mess at the dinner table; boy that’d give the young piss-ants something to jaw-bone about for the next 20 years or so.” He mused “probably good for a few laughs though”. Suddenly, the doorbell rang; or sort of. It was a three-chime affair when new, but now was reduced by age to one and a half chimes when it worked at all. “Come on in” he shouted from the kitchen as he craned his neck around the corner to make sure that friends were entering his musty-smelling house. It was Chrome Nozzle and right behind him Bob Noxious, his favorite EMT, who for once wasn’t carrying his red-colored crash bag slung over his shoulder. “Happy New Year, Bro.” as they both shook hands with the Crusty Old Firefighter. “We came by to drop off some beer and buffalo wings and help you set up; we left the wings on the porch since they’re still frozen and its colder then hell outside so they’ll be fine until you need them later on.” The Crusty Old Firefighter peered at them under his coke-bottle thick glasses. “You guys want some coffee? It’s on the stove, go over and help yourselves; the milk’s out on the counter.” While pouring his coffee, Bob Noxious looked over at his two compatriots and softly mentioned “You guys know that as of tonight at 12 midnight, the town is losing its ambulance service for a new one? I can’t believe they’d actually replace Crocket Ambulance after all they’ve helped us out over all these years!” “Boy, isn’t that the truth”, Chrome intoned. “Every time the town got into jam with one of these low-budgeted ambulance firms, Crocket always jumped into the fray to help the town out and now they’re going to dump them again for another one of these fly-by-night outfits. What’s the name of this new one they want to add? ”He asked inquisitively. “I think their called Transfusion Paramedics; they do a lot of work to the south of us in the city.” Bob replied. “From what I heard, they even overbid Crocket by a few thousand dollars, even so the town signed a contract with them!!” Chrome looked over at Bob, feeling his blood pressure rising. “This is ridiculous! It makes no sense at all; we’ve got a good working relationship with them, they know the district, there here when we need them, they’ve helped us out time after time when we’ve gotten burned by these other services the town signs up with; and what about our good friends, Ed Bagger and Sue Liner? They work so well with us at all the scenes. Something’s not right with this.” Ed Bagger was the regular paramedic assigned and Sue Liner was the EMT who regularly worked with Ed. “Hey easy Bro.” the Crusty Old Firefighter piped up. “There are ways to let the town know in a civil manner that you’re not happy with their selection. Rather then letting your blood pressure skyrocket over this, try sitting down and writing a letter to your representative on the Town Board? And show up at the meeting if they discuss your letter in public; that way you’ll get your feelings on the subject known to them. You never know, if we all sit here and bitch about how bad this is and how bad that is and not contact them to let them know our feelings, they won’t know how you feel about it. At least you know you tried. But to do nothing will accomplish exactly that.” Looking at the Crusty Old Firefighter Chrome replied “You know, your starting to sound like a broken record” “Perhaps” he retorted “But I know from experience that it has worked and maybe this time it will if you give it a shot.” Bob thoughtfully said, “You know, I think you’ve got a good point there; remember the year we went as a group to the Commissioners meeting and made a stand on having an air conditioner installed on the new rescue truck; at first they didn’t think we needed it due to the cost, but after we made rational arguments, they saw it our way and agreed to have air conditioning installed. Who knows? Maybe it might work if we try it.” Chrome walked over to the stove, lifted the lid of the pot that contained the super spicy chili, sniffed it deeply, replaced the lid and said sheepishly, “mmmm, damn good chili. Alright, I think that’s what I’m going to do then. In retrospect that really sounds like something we should try; after all I think we need to make sure the town monitors the service of Transfusion to see if we are getting the bang for the buck. Believe me, you can’t replace experience with a cheaper contract that easily; we’ll just have to see how they do and if we aren’t happy with the service we think we should be getting, then we’ll ask them reconsider our former ambulance service.” The Crusty Old Firefighter, leaned back in his chair, the bulk of his massive frame spilling out over the arms of the chair, farted wetly and smiled at both of his comrades in arms, knowing full well that they’d taken his suggestion seriously. Both Bob and Chrome wrinkled their noses at the offensive odor and moved diplomatically across the room to the cleaner air in the pantry. The Crusty Old Firefighter looked at them quizzically and said, “you know, not for nothing, even thought the Town Board decided to go with another service that some of us wouldn’t have gone with, I’m sure in their hearts they knew the decision they made was in the best interests for the residents of the town, so try not to be too hard on them! Well let’s get this place set up for our New Years Eve Party. The gang from the firehouse will be here shortly.” Bob, holding his nose said “well open up a window first, it reeks in here.”

Monday, January 12, 2009

Bah! Humbug!

It was a cold November night in Beekman; the wind whistled through the rafters; the smell of hickory wood burning in a freshly cleaned chimney wafted throughout the house. In a small cramped room nestled in the upper southwest attic of the house sat the wise firefighter, Chrome Nozzle, who’d been a firefighter for the past 25 years. Next to him on the table in a chipped, weather-beaten coffee mug labeled “Firemen are always in Heat” was a hot steaming cup of coffee. The Christmas tree in the corner was lit by about 6 or 7 dull bulbs and most of the ornaments had disappeared over the years. Even tho’ it was a rather sad looking tree, it fit perfectly in the musty-smelling attic. Chrome really enjoyed the camaraderie with his fellow firefighters and was the kind of person who always thought of them in the kindest of ways. Still being a believer in Santa, it became his call in history to always hope and pray that Santa would pay his firehouse a visit and drop off some well needed gifts for all of the firefighters there; even if there was no chimney. Besides, he mused, using the front door was a lot easier then getting dirty going down creosote blackened chimneys. He labored over his paper, squinting while he scribbled his yearly screed to Santa……….

Dear Santa,

It’s been a while since I last penned a letter to you groveling for gifts at the firehouse for myself and all my buddies here, cuz we really worked hard this year and we behaved for the most part, well most of us anyhow. I’d like you to consider the following; Please arrange to have the funding made available to remodel our fireman’s room so It won’t look like a cross between a sterile hospital room and a rustic moose hunting lodge minus the head trophies…..I’d love for you to buy a new thermal imaging camera for us...a change of mindset in the way we think so that someday we may form a Volunteer & Exempt Firemen’s Benevolent Association which benefits all the firemen as opposed to a select few…..louder pagers so our deaf members can hear their pagers open up at night and respond to all calls….I’d really love to wake up on Christmas morning and find Beekman’s “Taj Mahal” finished (including the onion domes) …..I’d love for you to send books entitled “The Importance of Volunteering” to all the firefighter/EMT’s; I think this would help them get our ambulance out of the bay once in a while so we don’t look like complete buffoons throughout the county…..while your at it please throw in a new front tooth for Captain Joe, so he can smile without looking like a picket fence… new toilets in the men’s room that don’t clog up when you put a job in them…new seats in 34-67 to replace the one’s broken by our larger sized members…But most importantly Santa, a year where all of our members and their families remain in good health and spirits.
Signed,


Chrome Nozzle,
Firefighter


Happy Holiday’s everyone!
, T

Pride

In a recent fire company meeting, a discussion was held regarding wearing full regulation dress uniforms, debate was held on whether or not to wear non-regulation uniforms to parades. The long and short of it ended up being that we will continue the long-standing tradition of wearing our regulation uniforms to parades. But what stood out in my mind during the debate was when someone brought up in defense that we should continue to wear them because even though they are uncomfortably warm during parades, “pride” dictates that we should wear them. Hmmm…I thought pride? That’s a term I don’t hear kicked around a lot at the fire station. What do we show pride in? When we wash the fire apparatus? Or rolling hose? Or perhaps at election time? After much thought and deliberation I found that I can’t really find much of what I thought was pride. So I looked it up in the Websters on-line dictionary and found this:

pride Pronunciation: \prīd\ Function:noun Etymology: Middle English, from Old English prȳde, from prūd proud — more at proud Date: before 12th century
1: the quality or state of being proud: as a: inordinate self-esteem : conceit b: a reasonable or justifiable self-respect c: delight or elation arising from some act, possession, or relationship 2: proud or disdainful behavior or treatment : disdain3 a: ostentatious display b: highest pitch : prime4: a source of pride : the best in a group or class5: a company of lions6: a showy or impressive group

This gave me a whole range of definitions but I figured it would be better used if I was able to put it into something simpler to read for all the Brothers and Sisters at the fire house; so here’s my definition of “pride” and how it relates to the fire service:
Pride is the feeling you get when you are at a fire scene and you’ve made a good stop; Pride is when you’re fire training has proven your confidence and ability to perform your duties as professionals; Pride is watching the backs of your Brother and Sister firefighters whether it be at a fire scene or a social function; Pride is honoring a deceased firefighter after he or she has answered their final alarm; Pride is following the orders of an officer whether you agree or not; Pride is the care you show when you use the fireman’s room for relaxing and entertainment and treat it as you would your own home; Pride is how you deal with the public on the fire ground; Pride is the respect of a fire fighters family when in their presence; Pride is the accountability for all your actions in life; Pride is getting out of bed at 3am to extinguish a small pile of burning leaves or help at a rescue call involving lifting an elderly person back onto their bed or chair; Pride is the ability to maintain your professionalism and dignity no matter what the situation whether in public or private; Pride is allowing someone to speak freely without holding a pique or grudge against them because of their position on a particular matter that you may or may not agree with; Pride is performing at least one good deed for someone per day no matter how trivial; Pride is comforting the parents or loved ones of someone who’s been in a auto accident or medical incident as opposed to looking the other way; Pride is remembering that we are all in this together and we are one band of Brothers & Sisters. If we claim we have pride we just can’t pick or choose from what we like, it must be all inclusive. How many of these can you honestly say you embrace??